Addressing Manufacturing Workforce Challenges: Our Future In Peril

By Dan Berry, President and CEO, MAGNET

Few conversations we here at MAGNET have with manufacturers about their operating challenges get very far without workforce considerations emerging as a central problem.  Unfortunately, we have learned that there are multiple dimensions to these challenges and that no single solution will fix them.

At one level, primarily among those companies looking for moderately skilled entry level workers, we often hear these sentiments.  “We’ll train them.  Just give us individuals who have basic reading, writing and math skills, who understand what it means to work, that show up every day on time, can follow directions, work as a member of a team and can pass a drug test. ”

Here is another refrain we often hear:  “The average age in my skilled workforce is 55 plus.  I am going to lose all my (insert machinists, welders, etc.) over the next several years and there is no source of replacements in sight.”

Other companies talk about the difficulty they’re having with finding highly skilled talent, often in various engineering disciplines.

So, the range of workforce challenges runs the gamut of education in the U.S. from what’s necessary in K-12 education to build the foundation for the workforce to the technical and community colleges, which develop the knowledge and applied skills, on up to what happens in our four year colleges to develop the highly educated professional.  One clear need across the educational spectrum is for more focus on the STEM disciplines—science, technology, engineering and math.

In Cleveland, MAGNET has joined with several community partners to focus more attention on STEM in a variety of ways. In addition, we have tackled the varied workforce challenges by addressing two related factors—quantity and quality.

Our work on quantity is aimed at building a pipeline of prospective workers interested in manufacturing careers.  Much of this has been through our Ambassador Program which involves marketing, media and educational programming with K-12 students, their parents and teachers to increase awareness about the great careers available in manufacturing.  In addition, we have worked with particular population groups, such as returning veterans, to interest them in, prepare them for, and connect them with, manufacturing career opportunities.

With regard to quality, one of major initiatives has been to work extensively with the National Association of Manufacturers’ (NAM) Manufacturing Institute on advancing a skill standards continuum from primary and secondary education to higher education.  The objective is to promote the use of an industry-based skills certification system that relies on competencies and standards that establish a common language to guide training, education and hiring.  We’re also involved with advancing several other projects, including the Automotive Manufacturing Technical Education Collaborative (AMTEC) and the Steel-Worker for the Future, which are based on the skills-standards approach.

Our experience thus far is surfacing some principles that we think are useful in responding to workforce issues regardless of where they are on the spectrum of challenges.

  • Engage employers directly in the problem definition and design of solutions
  • Build a commonly shared definition of the skills required that can be used to drive design of curricula and training programs.
  • Tie the formal training and education to various types of what is called “experiential learning”.  This means finding ways to connect the classroom learning with hands on work experience.  Internships, co-op education and apprenticeships are examples of this approach.

Unless we figure out how to address the various types of workforce challenges, the future of our manufacturing base is in peril.

We would love to hear from readers on which, if any, of these perspectives and principles reflect their company’s experience in addressing workforce challenges.  Are there other issues that we should be addressing?   We also would welcome your suggestions about best practice programs or strategies that we should be trying to emulate. Please comment below or drop me a note at with your comments and ideas.

The Manufacturing Advocacy & Growth Network (MAGNET) exists solely to help manufacturing companies in Northern Ohio become more competitive and grow. MAGNET is an Ohio Edison Technology Center, a contractor with the NIST Manufacturing Extension Partnership program administered through the Ohio Department of Development, and a part of the regional economic development system in Northeast Ohio.

Posted by MAGNET Ohio in Workforce-Development

Most Recent

Boosting Business through Responsible Growth

May 02, 2018 by MAGNET Ohio

Article submitted by Bank of America For mid-market companies, business success and responsible growth aren’t mutually exclusive. In fact, prioritizing responsible growth is becoming increasingly important, and successful companies are making sustainability central to their growth strategies. Beyond good corporate citizenship, they are recognizing the intrinsic link between the strength of their business and that of the communities and economies in which they operate. Leading your growth with those goals in mind builds resilience and better solutions for the future. Consider the following: Responsible growth companies perform better. Companies that consider the impact of risks and opportunities on the environment, local communities and society may produce better financial results than those that don’t. Additionally, 90% of companies believe a sustainability plan is important for remaining competitive. Responsible growth companies attract investment. A 2016 study by MIT Sloan Management Review and Boston Consulting Group surveyed 3,000 executives and managers from more than 100 countries. Findings revealed that 75% of senior executives in investment firms agree that a company’s sustainability performance is materially important to their investment decisions, and nearly half would not invest in a company with a poor sustainability record. Ninety percent of executives see sustainability as important, but only


February 22, 2018 by Sam Wasylyshyn

HEADLINE The survey definitively shows that product innovation leads to more growth, while “grow your own workforce” strategies will be needed to fill the major labor shortages hampering small manufacturer growth. Emerging technologies like the Internet of Things (IoT), 3D printing, and digital manufacturing are beginning to enhance innovation and productivity, but still have significant room for adoption amongst Ohio’s small manufacturing businesses. ABOUT THE SURVEY Under the direction of the Ohio Manufacturing Extension Partnership (Ohio MEP), MAGNET: The Manufacturing Advocacy and Growth Network conducted a thorough survey of Ohio’s manufacturing base. Contributing approximately 20% of Ohio’s jobs (and driving in some regions up to 50% of Ohio’s economy), and generating a disproportionate amount of export revenues and Gross Regional Product, manufacturing is critical to Ohio. Greater than 95% of Ohio’s manufacturers are small (under 500 employees), and these manufacturers need to remain competitive both nationally and internationally to ensure our economy’s health. Ohio’s Development Services Agency and the National Institute of Standards and Technology, which runs the MEP, recognizes the importance of this sector and fuels MAGNET and the Ohio MEP program to directly serve and support innovation, efficiency, and growth in small and medium manufacturers. What manufacturers need

Manufacturing is Facing a New Reality

February 06, 2018 by Sam Wasylyshyn

How Virtual Reality and Augmented Reality Can Help Keep Our Engineers Safe and Our Manufacturing Strong Recall how difficult it was to put together complex LEGO creations when you were a child or helping a child. Now, picture assembling a fighter plane from a room full of parts. Even highly trained engineers can benefit from technology to help improve consistency and quality. Virtual reality (VR) and augmented reality (AR) are making near-perfect assembly a possibility in the manufacturing space. By wearing AR glasses that use cameras, depth sensors and motion sensors to overlay images onto the real working environment, engineers and factory workers can visualize the exact bolts, parts, part numbers and instructions on how to assemble a particular component correctly. Lockheed Martin began using AR goggles and improved F-35 assembly time by 30 percent, in addition to increasing accuracy to 96 percent[1]. In order to remain competitive, businesses should consider the ways VR and AR can improve efficiency and supply chain productivity. According to a recent BofA Merrill Lynch Global Research report[2], AR platforms can provide companies up to 25 percent in cost savings on installation of equipment. Here are four ways VR/AR is disrupting the mid-market manufacturing space: